Reasons not to use positive reinforcement in dog training

3 March 2023

Bribery and more

A vizsla stands in the field

·     Your dog can have a lot of treats and obviously there is an obesity crisis happening for people and animals at the moment. Obesity is a new welfare concern listed by vets. One way around this is to treat your dog with food from their daily allowance such as their kibble.


·     If you use a clicker or marker word during training and click/use your marker at the wrong moment you can mark the wrong thing. For example if you ask your dog to leave an item and then they do, and you give them a treat then click while they are eating the treat they may associate the click with eating rather than leaving. Therefore guidance on timing is really important.


·     For dogs who have not learned impulse control they can jump up in anticipation of the treats. You can adjust your hand position to overcome this if you’re training loose lead walking. Rather than rewarding out of your hand when your dog walks politely you can put the treat on the floor. That way they are not jumping up in anticipation of the treat.


·     If used incorrectly you can bribe your pet. If you show your pet the treat and lure them then this can be a form of bribery. You can fade out the lure however if it is needed in early stages. However if you reward them after they’ve done the behaviour (place treats in a bag so they can't see them) then this is reinforcement: they are getting paid after completing the task.


·     If you treat the dog every single time then it can become very predictable and thus boring. It’s better to move on to a variable reward schedule – not giving a treat everytime – when you can.


·     You need to generalise the pet to different areas for it to work. It is harder to come away from 6 dogs than two. That’s why shaping (rewarding for small approximations) is important.


Positive reinforcement works, is kind and safer than alternatives. It's been used with zoo animals successfully but above are some things to watch out for and consider. I'm studying animal behaviour at university and have been informed about all of the different training methods. I use positive reinforcement alot in my training.


Here are definitions of the different forms of training.


Positive reinforcement – adding something to make a behaviour more likely such as food.


Positive punishment – adding something to make a behaviour less likely such as yanking on the lead or a loud noise.


Negative reinforcement – taking something away that is unpleasant when a dog adheres. Such as a choke chain loosening when a dog walks without pulling.


Negative punishment – no longer giving treats or stopping attention.


For something to be rewarding – it has to be thought of as rewarding by the individual. If a dog is given food but they find play more rewarding they may egnore food, therefore higher value food may be needed/ or a toy that they love. Similarly for something to be punishing it needs to be thought as punishing by the individual. You may have to escalate punishment which is a huge welfare concern as you could really hurt an animal using it and lead to physical and emotional damage.


Read more here.


by Lisa Sinnott 5 February 2025
Are puppy pads for toilet training the answer? When you’re toilet training your puppy it can be confusing to know what to do. You may have heard that puppy pad’s are the answer. Let’s discuss this. Remember that physically a pup’s bladder is very small.. they can’t hold it for too long! They don’t go to the bathroom indoors to spite you. Also remember that some dogs may not be going to the bathroom – they may be marking scent by doing very small pee’s.
by Lisa Sinnott 13 January 2025
I read a paper recently called An Investigation into the Impact of Pre-Adolescent Training on Canine Behavior by Dinwoodie and colleagues. The aim of the study was conducted to see whether training done prior to 3 months of age was more effective than doing training later. Here is what they found.
by Lisa Sinnott 6 January 2025
Christmas can be a difficult time for many reasons: lack of routine, new visitors coming into the home, lack of sleep, more noise.
by Lisa Sinnott 23 December 2024
Many people have dogs because they enjoy the social side of having a dog.. chatting to people in the park and watching their dogs bound around and play with each other. However, for many people I work with this isn’t their reality. Their dog may have had a bad experience with a dog and is now scared, or they could be recovering from an operation, for example. This can make walks – especially in narrow locations very difficult. If you, your self have had a dog who shows signs of reactivity then you’ll appreciate how hard it is and you may be doing the below already.. but if not please read on. · If you see a dog who is reactive walking down the street (perhaps they have a jacket that is yellow), or perhaps their handler just looks uneasy.. then walk across the road.. this will give a dog some breathing space. · Feed your dog to distract them rather than letting them get fixated on the other dog. · Change direction or if you can, wait behind a parked car so that the dogs do not notice each other. The above steps can really help a dog and their handler. Walking a reactive dog can feel stressful and anxiety inducing and people’s behaviour can really help the dog and the person.
by Lisa Sinnott 23 December 2024
Some things to teach/get started with, with your new puppy
by Lisa Sinnott 6 November 2024
Devastatingly, thousands of dogs end up in rescue centres each year, sometimes because people have financial problems or divorces and sometimes because of behavioural and health problems (behaviour and health are interlinked – pain can make a dog more grumpy and less tolerant). The pandemic and cost of living crisis means that rescue centres have seen the perfect storm of dogs arriving into their care.
by Lisa Sinnott 6 November 2024
If it’s going to be your puppy’s first Christmas this year here are some things to consider to make the day as safe for your pup and enjoyable for you and your family as possible. 
by Lisa Sinnott 2 November 2024
Considerations when hiring professional to work with your dog
by Lisa Sinnott 17 October 2024
If you’ve joined a puppy training class or are thinking about joining one you may be thinking about what training tasks are the biggest priority.. you want to focus on those that will benefit yours and your dogs life the most (of course tricks are ace, but life skills are the most important!). There are some classes that are purely socialisation where training tasks are not taught but I will cover that in a different blog.
by Lisa Sinnott 13 September 2024
My dog is doing a runner when I get their walking equipment out – why?
More posts
Share by: